ISLAMABAD: As global attention remains focused on Pakistan-hosted negotiations between the United States and Iran, several Indian media outlets have come under criticism for promoting what observers describe as misleading narratives while downplaying Islamabad’s diplomatic efforts to de-escalate tensions.
Delegations from Iran and the United States have arrived in Pakistan for high-level talks following a two-week ceasefire announced by Donald Trump after weeks of conflict involving US and Israeli strikes on Iran.
The Iranian delegation is led by Mohammad Baqer Qalibaf, while the US side is headed by JD Vance, underscoring the significance of the Pakistan-mediated dialogue aimed at achieving long-term peace.
Despite broad international recognition of Pakistan’s role, some Indian television channels continued to air critical narratives, drawing backlash from analysts, diplomats and social media users.
Short video clips circulating online show Indian anchors being challenged by foreign experts during live discussions. In one instance, Arnab Goswami questioned China-based analyst Victor Gao about the ceasefire developments. Gao began by crediting Pakistan for facilitating dialogue, but was interrupted before completing his remarks.
In another exchange, US diplomat Jeffrey Gunter dismissed concerns raised by Indian anchors regarding the safety of Vice President Vance during his visit to Pakistan. Responding to claims aired on Times Now, he criticised the discussion as turning into an unnecessary “Pakistan-versus-India circus”.
Gunter rebuked the panel, saying such speculation undermined the seriousness of ongoing diplomatic efforts and reflected poorly on the discourse surrounding a sensitive international issue.
Similarly, a report aired by India Today suggested that Vance might not travel to Pakistan, a claim that was contradicted by official developments as the US delegation proceeded with its visit.
Observers say the portrayal by certain segments of Indian media has failed to gain traction internationally, where leaders and officials have largely welcomed Pakistan’s role in facilitating dialogue between Washington and Tehran.
Global stakeholders have backed Islamabad’s efforts, viewing the talks as a crucial step towards de-escalation and a potential pathway to lasting peace in the Middle East.
The criticism highlights growing concerns over misinformation and the politicisation of sensitive diplomatic developments, particularly at a time when coordinated international efforts are underway to stabilise the region.